02
Feb

Pool.com (C&R) Shame on you!

Archived in the category: Domain News
Posted by: Jamie Zoch -

Today I was doing a little surfing around and came across Pool.com’s (C&R) Catch and Release. In other words Domain Tasting with a fancy name!

To me, this is a clear slap in the face to ICANN, with Pool stating, “look what we can do with this loophole”. Clearly they are offering a service to profit on and take full advantage of the AGP, as it was not intended to be! Another catchy slogan they use… Evaluate Domains for as low as 10 Cents! If your not happy, simply delete the domain with in 4 1/2 days and it only cost you 10 cents etc. https://www.pool.com/CNRLanding.aspx

From what I can tell, they use Rebel.com for this. This might be a way for them to try and keep there name clean or they are using technology from Rebel. You can read more about this in there FAQ’sand also clearly see how they talk about monetizing the domains in this 4.5 day period etc which they call “Domains in Evaluation”.

This is what the page says exactly.

“When a domain is added to your Domains in Evaluation list, you can evaluate its value by pointing it to the DNS of your current monetization service. To ensure you get the most out of Catch & Release (C&R), remember to specify your DNS on the C&R Credit page (if they are different than your default DNS servers specified in your Pool.com account preferences). C&R will automatically direct your domains to your monetization service for a 4.5 day period immediately after they are added to your Evaluation list. “

If domain tasting is taken away or not with the fee’s ICANN discussed in the last meeting, Pool deserves a slap on the wrist for clearly misusing the AGP IMO. I do not see Moniker.com or Godaddy.comor any other ICANN Accredited registrars clearly offering domain name tasting!

Jamie Zoch (www.DotWeekly.com)

2 comments for “Pool.com (C&R) Shame on you!”

1
Patrick McDermott

Hi,

Catch and Release is not new. Pool has been offering it since December 2006 so they’re not thumbing their nose at ICANN.

From DomainInformer.com:
“Pool.com Launches “Catch & Release” Service for Domain Acquisition Support”
http://www.domaininformer.com/news/press/061204Pool.html
——
“I do not see Moniker.com…or any other ICANN Accredited registrars clearly offering domain name tasting!”

Look again…and you shall see!

Moniker has been offering domain tasting for quite some time although they don’t exactly come out and call it that.

When you register a domain at Moniker it automatically goes into the 4 day grace period.

You do not have to do anything.

Therefore you can correct an error or change your mind or “taste” a domain.

If you cancel it within 4 days (96 hours) you’ll get a refund in the form of a credit to your account minus 25 cents.

From Moniker:
“For a limited time, Moniker will be allowing customers to delete .com, .net, .info, .org, .biz, .us and .mobi names registered within 96 hours of their creation date. Customers will be credited back the original registration fee to their Moniker Accounts and charged a small transaction fee during this time frame for all names successfully deleted. Please note there will be no refunds only credits back to your Moniker account. This will allow customers to correct domain registration mistakes and / or delete .com and .net domains that are not desired during this time frame for a fraction of the original registration fee.”

Dynadot.com also allows domain tasting without the 25 cent fee.

There was nothing wrong with Pool or Moniker or Dynadot offering this.

An individual isn’t tasting millions of domains and not likely kiting the domains by registering and deleting the same domains over and over.

All 3 companies were following the guidelines
although domain tasting does violate the spirit of the 5 day AGP.

Obviously these offerings will change now after ICANN’s announcement last week.

Patrick

February 2nd, 2008 at 12:12 pm
2
admin

Man good points Patrick.
The article is more to point out that pool is simply offering the service “more in the open” then other registrars.

It’s a fact that EVERY registrar has and can delete domain names for free (but charge you for it), but Pool is displaying it nearly as a “service” and puts the service on there homepage. They call the service C&R etc. They could just say, Domain Tasting Here, instead of making up some fancy name. lol :)

February 2nd, 2008 at 12:36 pm

Leave a Reply





Sale! $7.49 .com at Go Daddy GoDaddy.com 120x60

Once You Know, You Newegg





Add to Technorati Favorites